All About Diamond Grading

Article By Admin

Feb 11, 2019

When buying a diamond, the most important assurance is that it should come with a certificate by an internationally recognized gemological authority. It is a form of validation by trained professionals in the field, of the quality of your diamond. Leading authorities includes the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), American Gemological Society (AGS) and International Gemological Institute (IGI). That being said, is one better than another?

Key Gemlogical Laboratories

GIA is one of the foremost gemological authority in the world. Established in 1931, it has entrenched itself as a key player in the field of diamond grading. The convention of 4Cs of diamond grading was developed by GIA and it has since been a gold standard in diamond grading. AGS was established in 1934, initially to cater to the United States domestic jewelry market, serving as a market standard. It soon expanded and is one of the key institutes worldwide. They utilize their own numeric scale of diamond grading, based on the grading standard developed by GIA. IGI was established in 1975 in Antwerp, the diamond capital of the world. Since then it has stood against the well-established institutes like GIA and AGS, who had accumulated 40 odd years of followings.

Research from an Empirical Perspective

Joseph Lee from Diamond Screener took an empirical approach to compare the certification standards of the gemological institutions, using dual certified diamonds (GIA and IGI) from inventories of Blue Nile and James Allen.

The study is based on 29 dual certified stones, and the grading of cut and color was analysed, yielding 58 comparisons. 32 comparison showed same grading standards, while GIA was stricter on 11 occasions and IGI was stricter on 15 occasions. Of these occurrence of differences in grading, the differences were a single unit apart, which was an acceptable deviation, with the exception of two comparison. One of which was GIA grading color of the diamond as ‘I’, while IGI graded it a ‘G’, two units apart. Both grades falls under the ‘near-colorless’ band. On the other occasion, GIA graded the clarity of a diamond as ‘VVS1’, while IGI graded it as ‘VS1’. The conclusion that can be drawn is that the grading was consistent between the two gemological laboratories and difference were mainly one unit apart (except for two comparisons).

Research from an Experimental Perspective

Another study came from Rapaport group, a network of companies providing value added service supporting fair and transparent diamond and jewelry market. They compared grading standards on six grading labs. To conduct the study, they sent 10 diamonds to six grading labs worldwide. With the grading report, they normalized the results on a ‘quality index’, whereby the lower the number the less lenient they are. Results showed that GIA was the strictest (at 14.8), with IGI trailing behind by one basis point (14.9). Median was at 15.9, while the ceiling was at 19.8.

Apart from that, the diamonds’ pricing was extrapolated from similar diamonds with similar quality on the Rapnet database. Data showed that GIA would yield the most revenue (i.e. being sold at the highest price), while revenue for IGI would rank fourth. This showed that while grading are consistent with GIA, their pricing are significantly lower than what the quality would deserve. This highlights a discounts for the consumers that cost are borne by the jewelers.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while diamond grading could be a somewhat subjective field, these variation do not stray much among these laboratories. The analysis of multitudes of grades of gems have only made the standards more consistent. In fact, these gemological institutes have only made buying a diamond more transparent than ever.

Related Articles

Jan 7, 2012
Classic

Template: Sticky

This is a sticky post. There are a few things to verify: The sticky post should be distinctly recognizable in some way in comparison to normal posts. You can style the .sticky class if you are using the post_class() function to generate your post classes, which is a best practice. They should show at the[…]

READ THE ARTICLE
Feb 11, 2019
GUIDE AND EDUCATION

Caring for Your Jewelry

Although diamonds may be the hardest material in the world, it is not indestructible. Some care have to be given to ensure that your jewelry stays in pristine condition. A careless knock may cause it to chip. This article will provide some tips to care for your diamonds and jewelry. Protecting your Jewellery It is[…]

READ THE ARTICLE
Feb 11, 2019
The Better Diamond
GUIDE AND EDUCATION

Engagement Ring Shopping Guide

Introduction An engagement ring is probably the most important piece of jewelry a guy would ever purchase. There are multitudes of options when choosing a ring, from ring design, material, size, shape, down to the diamond itself. In tradition jewelry store, the pieces are usually what are displayed over the counter. What it meant is[…]

READ THE ARTICLE
Feb 11, 2019
NEWS

All About Diamond Grading

When buying a diamond, the most important assurance is that it should come with a certificate by an internationally recognized gemological authority. It is a form of validation by trained professionals in the field, of the quality of your diamond. Leading authorities includes the Gemological Institute of America (GIA), American Gemological Society (AGS) and International[…]

READ THE ARTICLE

SIGN UP FOR OUR EMAIL

*By signing up you confirm that you have read the Privacy Policy and agree that your email will be collected and used by The Better Diamond for the purposes of sending news, promotions and updates via email. You can withdraw your consent at any time by unsubscribing or contacting us via admin@thebetterdiamond.com